You Say Potato, I say Po-data: Physical Template Tools for Visualization Authoring
Extended Material
Providing data visualization authoring tools for the general public remains an ongoing challenge. Inspired by block-printing, we explore how visualization stamps as a physical visualization authoring tool could leverage both visual freedom and ease of repetition. We conducted a workshop with two groups—visualization experts and non-experts—where participants authored visualizations on paper using hand-carved stamps made from potatoes and sponges. The low-fidelity medium freed participants to test new stamp patterns and accept mistakes. From the created visualizations, we observed several unique traits and uses of block-printing tools for visualization authoring, including: modularity of patterns, annotation guides, creation of multiple patterns from one stamp, and various techniques to apply data onto paper. We discuss the issues around expressivity and effectiveness of block-printed stamps in visualization authoring, and identify implications for the design and assembly of primitives in potential visualization stamp kits, as well as applications for future use in non-digital environments.
Authors:
Tiffany Wun
twwun@ucalgary.ca
Lora Oehlberg
lora.oehlberg@ucalgary.ca
Miriam Sturdee
miriam.sturdee@ucalgary.ca
Sheelagh Carpendale
sheelagh@ucalgary.ca
twwun@ucalgary.ca
lora.oehlberg@ucalgary.ca
miriam.sturdee@ucalgary.ca
sheelagh@ucalgary.ca
Paper (Preprint) · Bibtex
Video · Photos · Figures · Study Materials · Data Analysis
·
Conditionally accepted at ACM TEI 2019.
Final copy of paper to appear soon; content may change as such.
Bibtex
TBA
Videos
Teaser video for ACM TEI 2019.Photos
Photos of the participants' created stamps and visualizations during the study. Participants were divided into two groups to accommodate for the size of the room: Group 1 and Group 2.Click on the photos to enlarge them.
Figures
These figures didn't make the final cut of the paper, but you can click on the images to download them. Feel free to adapt as needed.Study Materials
Study-related materials found here.
Study Dataset
This is a fictional travel dataset about a four-day vacation. Numbers were placed between 10-70 to avoid a large skew in any direction. Download
Study Protocol
Study protocol for each workshop. Download
Introduction Slides
Slides used to present an introduction to block-printing stamps, data mappings, tasks, and the study in general. Download
Stamp Making Station
A picture of each participant's "stamp making station" shown in the intro slides. Download
Data Mapping Lookup Sheet
A picture of the "data mapping lookup sheet" we made available to participants during the workshop (then called "data mapping cheat sheet"). Download
Demographic Questionnaire
The demographic questionnaire provided to participants at the beginning of the study. Download
Post-Study Questionnaire
The post-study questionnaire provided to participants at the end of the study. Download
Semi-Structured Interview Forms
Participants could also further elaborate on their thoughts in a semi-structured interview sometime after the study. This interview was completely optional and would be conducted outside of the workshop. Download
Data Analysis
Study-related materials found here.
Data Analysis
Spreadsheet analaysis of the participants' created stamps and visualizations with respect to the stamp variables, stamp categories, data encodings, and annotations. Download